Remember the electrifying performance that left fans buzzing? Jarrett Stidham’s breakout game against the 49ers wasn’t just a fluke—it was a glimpse of what he could bring to the table. But here’s where it gets controversial: Can he replicate that magic in the high-stakes Patriots-Broncos playoff showdown? Let’s dive in.
It was Week 17 of the 2022 season, and the San Francisco 49ers, sitting comfortably at 11-4, were gearing up to face the Las Vegas Raiders on the road. Enter Jarrett Stidham, who hadn’t attempted a pass in two months but was suddenly thrust into the starting role. The betting lines shifted dramatically—the Niners went from -5 to -9.5-point favorites—but Stidham wasn’t intimidated. He started the game on fire, completing 6 of his first 7 passes for 114 yards, including three jaw-dropping deep throws. By halftime, he had marched the Raiders into 49ers territory on every drive, capping it off with a pinpoint touchdown pass to Davante Adams that left everyone in awe.
And this is the part most people miss: Stidham’s final stat line—22-for-34, 365 yards, three touchdowns, and two interceptions—tells only part of the story. Yes, the interceptions were costly, but his ability to keep the Raiders competitive forced the game into overtime, proving he could handle pressure. Now, he’s stepping into a game that quarterbacks dream of: the AFC Championship between the Denver Broncos and New England Patriots. While Drake Maye and the Patriots are favored, that assumption hinges on the idea that Stidham is a significant downgrade from Bo Nix. But is he?
Here’s the twist: Drake Maye, as talented as he is, faced relentless pressure last week against the Houston Texans—something the Broncos’ formidable pass rush is more than capable of replicating. Sure, Maye will make plays, but at what cost? Sacks and turnovers, as we saw last week, could swing the game in Denver’s favor. So, the real question isn’t whether Stidham is worse than Maye—it’s whether he can outduel him under the bright lights. And with Sean Payton calling the shots, expect some clever play designs to maximize Stidham’s strengths. Keep an eye on R.J. Harvey, who could have a breakout day, and don’t be surprised if Stidham does just enough to keep the Broncos in it.
Controversial take: This game won’t be decided by quarterback play alone—it’ll come down to which team can impose their will on the ground and in the trenches. The Broncos, playing at home, have the edge in a high-scoring affair. Prediction? Broncos 27, Patriots 20. But what do you think? Is Stidham up to the task, or will Maye prove the doubters wrong? Let’s hear your take in the comments!
